[ENG VER] Google Cloud vs Microsoft Azure vs AWS: Here's a Comparison of the Three Cloud Services!

Assalamu‘alaikum wr. wb.

Hello guys! Cloud Computing is currently in great demand in the Industrial and Business world. And it is very helpful when doing any work. For that, a Cloud Service is needed, such as Google Cloud Platform (GCP), Microsoft Azure, and Amazon Web Services (AWS). This time, we will compare the three Cloud Services.

Article Sources : Digitalocean.com, BMC.com (Blogs), Cloudfresh.com (Blog), Coursera.org, and Berca.co.id

DEFINITION AND OVERVIEW

AWS, Azure, and GCP are the largest cloud providers today, but each has nuances and backgrounds. Here’s some basic information about each provider before we get into the specifics of how they differ :

1. Microsoft Azure

Microsoft Azure ranks as the second-largest cloud platform. Launched in 2010, Azure has grown into a platform offering over 200 products and services and is currently one of the fastest-growing cloud platforms.

Microsoft designed Azure to offer a broad range of services, particularly beneficial for enterprises that primarily use Microsoft products, facilitating a seamless transition to cloud or hybrid-cloud environments for many organizations. Over 95% of Fortune 500 companies use Microsoft Azure, demonstrating its reliability and effectiveness for enterprise users.

Moreover, Azure isn't limited to Windows-based services. It also supports open-source languages, technologies, and platforms, allowing users the flexibility to develop and maintain any application.

These are the Companies/Agencies/Institutions that use Microsoft Azure :

• Bosch
• Audi
• ASOS
• HSBC
• Starbucks
• Walgreens
• 3M
• FedEx
• Walmart
• HP
• Mitsubishi Electric
• Renault

2. Google Cloud Platform (GCP)

Google Cloud Platform (GCP) is the cloud service provided by Google and falls under the larger Google Cloud umbrella.

Publicly available since 2010, GCP offers over 100 services covering areas such as computing, networking, and big data. Today, GCP includes services like Google Workspace, enterprise Android, and Chrome OS.

Although GCP is the smallest among the Big 3 cloud providers when compared to AWS and Azure, it still delivers a comprehensive suite of cloud services capable of supporting and powering a wide range of applications.

These are the Companies/Agencies/Institutions that use Google Cloud :

• Toyota
• Equifax
• Nintendo
• Spotify
• The Home Depot
• Target
• X/Twitter
• PayPal
• UPS

3. Amazon Web Services (AWS)

Amazon Web Services (AWS), a subsidiary of Amazon.com, Inc., currently leads the market in cloud computing platforms. AWS is a highly developed cloud platform that provides a wide array of services suitable for individual developers, large corporations, and even governmental bodies.

Initially, AWS was created as an internal cloud solution. By 2006, it had expanded into a public cloud platform, offering services such as Amazon S3 cloud storage and Elastic Compute Cloud (EC2). Today, AWS provides over 200 fully developed services to meet various needs, serving millions of users worldwide.

These are the Companies/Agencies/Institutions that use AWS :

• Coursera
• Expedia
• Netflix
• Coinbase
• Formula 1
• Intuit
• Airbnb
• Lyft
• Food and Drug Administration (FDA)
• Coca Cola

COMPARISONS

Here are some comparisons of the three cloud services such as Google Cloud, Microsoft Azure, and AWS.

A. Google Cloud (GCP)

Below are some features of Google Cloud (GCP) :

1. Product Offerings

GCP menyediakan sumber daya komputasi melalui Google Compute Engine, menawarkan instance VM yang dapat disesuaikan.

Google Compute Engine menyediakan jenis mesin yang telah ditentukan sebelumnya dan jenis mesin kustom, memungkinkan pengguna untuk menyesuaikan sumber daya sesuai dengan kebutuhan mereka.

Untuk komputasi tanpa server, GCP menawarkan Google Cloud Functions, memungkinkan pengembang menjalankan fungsi berbasis peristiwa tanpa mengelola server.

2. Data Centers

Pusat data GCP secara strategis terletak di berbagai wilayah di seluruh dunia, mencakup Amerika Utara, Eropa, Asia, Australia, dan Amerika Selatan.

Meskipun GCP memiliki jumlah pusat data yang lebih kecil dibandingkan AWS dan Azure, mereka dikenal karena infrastruktur jaringan global berkinerja tinggi.

Keahlian Google dalam optimalisasi jaringan memastikan transfer data cepat dan koneksi latensi rendah, menjadikan GCP pilihan yang disukai untuk aplikasi yang sensitif terhadap latensi.

3. Pricing

GCP menggunakan model bayar sesuai penggunaan dengan jenis mesin yang telah ditentukan dan kustom.

Biaya penyimpanan didasarkan pada kapasitas dan frekuensi akses untuk Google Cloud Storage dan Google Persistent Disk.

Biaya transfer data bervariasi berdasarkan jumlah data yang dikirim dan diterima.

Diskon tersedia melalui Committed Use Contracts dengan komitmen di muka untuk satu atau tiga tahun.

Tiga tingkatan dukungan yang tersedia - Basic, Development, dan Production, dengan tingkat cakupan dukungan dan waktu respons yang berbeda.

4. Use Cases

Keahlian dalam data dan analitik: Google Cloud Platform unggul dalam manajemen data dan analitik, menjadikannya pilihan yang baik untuk bisnis yang bergantung pada pemrosesan data besar dan pembelajaran mesin.

Kepiawaian dalam Kubernetes: Keahlian Google dalam Kubernetes dan containerization menarik bagi perusahaan yang ingin menerapkan aplikasi berbasis kontainer.

Performa dan jaringan: Jaringan global berkinerja tinggi dari Google Cloud Platform membantu memastikan latensi rendah dan transfer data cepat, membuatnya cocok untuk aplikasi yang memerlukan waktu respons cepat.

B. Microsoft Azure

Below are some features of Microsoft Azure :

1. Product Offerings

Azure menawarkan sumber daya komputasi serupa dengan layanan Mesin Virtual (VMs), menyediakan lingkungan komputasi virtual yang dapat diskalakan dan fleksibel.

Mesin Virtual Azure menawarkan berbagai ukuran instance untuk memenuhi berbagai persyaratan beban kerja, termasuk yang dioptimalkan untuk memori, komputasi, dan penyimpanan.

Selain itu, Azure menyediakan Azure Functions untuk komputasi tanpa server, memungkinkan pengembang menjalankan fungsi berbasis peristiwa tanpa perlu khawatir tentang infrastruktur yang mendasarinya.

2. Data Centers

Azure memiliki jaringan pusat data yang luas di seluruh dunia, menawarkan layanan di lebih banyak wilayah dibandingkan AWS dan GCP.

Microsoft terus memperluas jejak pusat data mereka, dengan kehadiran yang kuat di Amerika Utara, Eropa, Asia, dan Australia.

Pusat data Azure terintegrasi dengan tulang punggung jaringan Microsoft yang luas, memastikan transfer data berkecepatan tinggi dan konektivitas latensi rendah.

3. Pricing

Azure menggunakan model bayar sesuai penggunaan dan menawarkan Reserved VM Instances untuk penghematan biaya.

Keluarga instance dioptimalkan untuk beban kerja yang berbeda.

Biaya penyimpanan didasarkan pada kapasitas dan penggunaan untuk Azure Blob Storage dan Azure Disk Storage.

Umumnya menawarkan ingress gratis, sementara biaya egress diterapkan berdasarkan volume data dan wilayah.

Diskon volume melalui Azure Hybrid Benefit untuk pelanggan dengan lisensi yang ada.

4. Kasus Penggunaan

Integrasi dengan ekosistem Microsoft: Untuk organisasi yang berinvestasi dalam produk Microsoft, Azure menawarkan integrasi yang mulus, memungkinkan penerapan cloud hybrid dan migrasi yang lancar. Azure juga menawarkan mesin virtual berbasis Windows, yang tidak semua penyedia cloud tawarkan.

Solusi cloud hybrid: Azure adalah pilihan yang disukai untuk bisnis dengan infrastruktur lokal, menawarkan kemampuan layanan komputasi cloud hybrid yang kuat.

Penekanan kuat pada keamanan: Dengan fokus pada kepatuhan dan fitur keamanan, Azure cocok untuk industri dengan regulasi data yang ketat.

C. Amazon Web Services (AWS)

Below are some features of Amazon Web Services (AWS) :

1. Product Offerings

AWS menyediakan berbagai sumber daya komputasi, termasuk Amazon EC2 (Elastic Compute Cloud), yang menawarkan cloud pribadi virtual yang dapat diskalakan untuk berbagai penggunaan.

EC2 menyediakan berbagai jenis instance, masing-masing dioptimalkan untuk beban kerja tertentu seperti penggunaan umum, intensif memori, dan instance bertenaga GPU.

AWS juga menawarkan komputasi tanpa server dengan AWS Lambda, memungkinkan pengembang menjalankan kode tanpa perlu menyusun atau mengelola server.

2. Data Centers

AWS mengoperasikan jaringan global yang luas dengan lebih dari 200 pusat data yang tersebar di berbagai wilayah geografis, mencakup Amerika Utara, Eropa, Asia, Australia, dan Amerika Selatan.

Mereka memiliki jumlah pusat data terbesar di antara tiga penyedia cloud hiperskala, dengan kehadiran signifikan di wilayah seperti Virginia Utara, Oregon, dan Frankfurt.

Infrastruktur pusat data AWS yang luas memungkinkan bisnis untuk mengerahkan sumber daya lebih dekat ke pengguna akhir, mengurangi latensi dan meningkatkan kinerja.

3. Pricing

AWS menawarkan model bayar sesuai penggunaan dengan fleksibilitas dan kontrol biaya.

Menawarkan berbagai jenis instance dengan harga yang berbeda berdasarkan kinerja dan kapasitas.

Biaya penyimpanan didasarkan pada kapasitas dan pola akses untuk layanan seperti Amazon S3 dan Amazon EBS.

Ingress (data yang diterima) biasanya gratis, sementara egress (data yang dikirim) bervariasi berdasarkan volume dan wilayah, tetapi biasanya berkisar antara $0,05 hingga $0,09 per GB di berbagai antarmuka jaringan dan rencana harga.

Diskon tersedia melalui Reserved Instances dan AWS Savings Plans dengan pembayaran di muka.

4. Use Cases

Jangkauan global dan skalabilitas: AWS merupakan pilihan yang sangat baik untuk bisnis yang membutuhkan kehadiran global yang besar dan skalabilitas, berkat jaringan pusat data yang luas di seluruh dunia.

Beragam layanan: Dengan berbagai layanan yang sangat luas, AWS melayani berbagai kasus penggunaan, termasuk hosting web, AI, analitik, IoT, dan lainnya.

Ekosistem yang matang: Basis pelanggan yang mapan dan dukungan komunitas yang luas membuat AWS cocok untuk banyak pengguna, terutama perusahaan besar.

COMPARISON OF TABLES AND FIGURES

AWS and Azure have the largest service catalogs, offering over 200 services. GCP currently offers around 100+ services. Here's a general breakdown of the services :

• AWS has the largest service catalog.
• Azure ranks second with impressive AI, ML, and analytics services.
• Google Cloud Platform ranks third in the number of services offered.

In this section, let's look at the common service offerings from each cloud platform.

A. Services

1. Compute Services

SERVICE	AWS	AZURE	GCP
VM (Compute Instance)	EC2 (Elastic Compute)	Azure Virtual Machine	Google Compute Engine
PaaS	AWS Elastic Beanstalk	App Service	Google App Engine
Container	AWS Elastic Container / Kubernetes Service	Azure Kubernetes Service (AKS)	Google Kubernetes Engine
Serverless Functions	AWS Lambda	Azure Function	Google Cloud Functions

2. Database & Storage Services

SERVICE	AWS	AZURE	GCP
RDBMS (Multiple Database Types – SQL, MySQL, etc..)	AWS RDS	Azure SQL/ Database for MySQL/PostgreSQL	Cloud SQL
NoSQL	DynamoDB, Simple DB	Azure Cosmos DB, Table Storage	BigTable, Cloud Datastore
Object Storage	S3 (Simple Storage Service)	Blob Storage	Google Cloud Storage
File Storage	Elastic File System	Azure File Storage	Google Filestore
Archive Storage	Amazon Glacier	Azure Archive Storage	Google Storage (Archive Storage)
Data Warehouse / Data Lake	Amazon Redshift	Azure Synapse Analytics	Google BigQuery

3. Networking

SERVICE	AWS	AZURE	GCP
Virtual Network	Virtual Private Cloud (VPC)	Virtual Network (Vnet)	Virtual Private Cloud (VPC)
Load Balancing	Elastic Load Balancer	Azure Load Balancer	Google Cloud Load Balancing
Firewall	AWS Firewall / Web Application Firewall	Azure Firewall	Google Cloud Firewalls
DNS	Route 53	Azure DNS	Google Cloud DNS
CDN	Amazon CloudFront	Azure Content Delivery Network (CDN)	Cloud CDN

As you can see, all three service providers offer comparable services to meet the general computing needs of users. However, there are fundamental differences in two general categories :

• How each service is implemented within its respective cloud platform.
• The individual features are available for each service.

4. Special Services

Regarding specialized services, we see significant differences in the offerings available with AWS and Azure, which go far beyond GCP.

SERVICE	AWS	AZURE	GCP
DevOps	CodePipeline, CodeBuild, CodeDeploy, CodeStar	Azure Boards, Pipelines, Repos, Test Plans, Artifacts	GCP DevOps CloudBuild, Artifact Registry
AI & ML	Amazon SageMaker, Amazon Comprehend, Amazon Lex, Amazon Polly	Azure Machine Learning, Azure Databricks, Azure Cognitive Search, Azure Bot Service, Cognitive Services	Vertex AI, AutoML, Dataflow CX, Cloud Vision, Virtual Agents
IoT	FreeRTOS, IoT Core, Greengrass, IoT Analytics, SiteWise	Azure IoT Hub/Central, IoT Edge, Azure Sphere, Azure RTOS	Google Cloud IoT Core
AR & VR	Amazon Sumerian	Azure Mixed Reality (Spatial Anchors/Remote Rendering)	ARCore
Game Development	Amazon GameLift	Azure PlayFab	-
Business Analytics	Amazon Quicksight	Azure Power BI	Looker Studio
End-User Computing	Amazon Workspaces	Azure Virtual Desktop	-
Robotics	AWS RoboMaker	-	-

B. Advantages & Disadvantages (Pro & Cons)

The following are the Advantages and Disadvantages (Pros and Cons) of the Three Cloud Services such as Google Cloud, Microsoft Azure, and AWS.

1. Microsoft Azure

Pros	Cons
Extensive Integration with Microsoft Products	Pricing Complexity
Seamless integration with Microsoft products such as Windows Server, Active Directory, and Office 365.	The complex pricing structure can be difficult to understand and predict without careful planning.
Hybrid Cloud Capabilities	Learning Curve
Strong support for hybrid cloud environments, allowing integration of on-premises infrastructure with the cloud.	It can be complex to learn and manage, especially for users not familiar with Microsoft's ecosystem.
Global Reach	Support Costs
A large number of data centers worldwide, ensure low latency and high availability.	Premium support plans can be costly compared to some other cloud providers.
Comprehensive Compliance Offerings	Service Availability in Regions
Extensive range of compliance certifications and a focus on regulatory requirements.	Some services might not be available in all regions, potentially limiting deployment options.
Enterprise-Grade Solutions	Management Tools
Offers a wide range of enterprise-grade solutions including AI, analytics, and IoT.	Management tools can be complex and may require specialized knowledge.
Advanced Analytics and AI Services	Performance Variability
Provides robust analytics and AI services such as Azure Machine Learning and Azure Synapse Analytics.	Performance can vary depending on the specific service and region.
Developer Tools and DevOps Integration	Documentation Quality
Excellent integration with developer tools and DevOps services, including Visual Studio and GitHub.	While improving, some users find Azure's documentation less comprehensive compared to AWS.
Security Features	Feature Maturity
Strong security features, including advanced threat detection and identity management.	Certain newer services might not be as mature as similar offerings from AWS.
Flexible Pricing Options	Service Outages
Offers various pricing models, including pay-as-you-go and reserved instances, providing cost flexibility.	Like any cloud service, Azure is not immune to occasional service outages.
Rich Ecosystem and Marketplace	Resource Management
Extensive ecosystem and marketplace for third-party applications and services.	Managing resources and costs effectively requires careful planning and monitoring.

2. Google Cloud Platform (GCP)

Pros	Cons
Global Network	Pricing Complexity
GCP has a robust global network, ensuring low-latency connections and high availability.	The pricing structure can be complex and hard to predict without careful planning.
Advanced Data and Analytics Services	Learning Curve
Offers advanced services like BigQuery for data analytics and AI/ML services with Vertex AI.	The platform can be complex to learn, especially for beginners.
Strong Security	Support Costs
GCP provides strong security features, including encryption, IAM, and compliance certifications.	Dedicated support can be costly compared to some competitors.
Scalability	Service Availability
GCP offers excellent scalability options, allowing businesses to grow without worrying about infrastructure.	Not all services are available in every region, which can be a limitation for some global businesses.
Innovative AI/ML Capabilities	Market Share
Leading in AI and ML services, providing tools like TensorFlow and advanced APIs.	GCP has a smaller market share compared to AWS and Azure, which might affect community support and resources.
Flexible Pricing Models	Ecosystem Integration
Offers flexible pricing models including sustained use discounts and committed use contracts.	Integration with non-Google ecosystems might require additional tools and management.
Kubernetes and Container Support	Service Maturity
Strong support for Kubernetes (GKE) and containerized applications.	Some services are newer and might not be as mature as similar offerings from AWS and Azure.
Comprehensive Free Tier	Feature Set
Offers a comprehensive free tier for many services, making it easier to get started.	Certain enterprise features might still lag behind those offered by AWS or Azure.
Strong Integration with Google Services	Resource Management
Excellent integration with other Google services like Gmail, Google Drive, and Google Workspace.	Resource management tools might not be as intuitive or mature compared to competitors.
Sustainability Efforts	Limited Hybrid Cloud Support
GCP is known for its strong commitment to sustainability and renewable energy.	Hybrid cloud support is improving but still not as robust as some competitors.

3. Amazon Web Services (AWS)

Pros	Cons
Comprehensive Service Offering	Complex Pricing Structure
Extensive range of services covering computing, storage, networking, databases, machine learning, and more.	Pricing can be complex and difficult to understand, making it challenging to predict costs.
Global Reach and Availability	Steep Learning Curve
Data centers in many regions worldwide, ensure low latency and high availability.	It can be complex to learn and manage, especially for beginners.
Scalability and Flexibility	Costs Can Add Up
Highly scalable infrastructure that can handle varying workloads efficiently.	Costs can escalate quickly if services are not monitored and managed effectively.
Strong Security Features	Service Limits
Advanced security features including encryption, compliance certifications, and identity management.	Initial service limits may require adjustments based on specific needs.
Rich Ecosystem and Marketplace	Documentation Quality
A large ecosystem of third-party tools and applications is available in the AWS Marketplace.	While extensive, some users find AWS documentation overwhelming or lacking in certain areas.
Innovative and Up-to-date Services	Service Outages
Regularly updates and introduces new services and features, staying ahead of technology trends.	Like all cloud providers, AWS experiences occasional service outages.
Wide Range of Instance Types	Vendor Lock-In
Offers a variety of instance types to match different workloads and performance needs.	Potential for vendor lock-in, making it difficult to switch providers.
Robust Support for Hybrid Cloud	Management Tools Complexity
Supports hybrid cloud setups, allowing integration of on-premises infrastructure with AWS.	Management and monitoring tools can be complex and may require expertise.
Advanced Networking Features	Billing and Account Management
Comprehensive networking options including VPC, Direct Connect, and advanced routing capabilities.	Billing and account management can be complex, requiring careful tracking of usage and costs.
Strong Community and Support	Resource Management
Active community and extensive support options, including enterprise-level support plans.	Effective resource management requires careful planning and continuous monitoring.

C. Image Comparisons

The following is an Image for the List of Services from the Three Services such as Microsoft Azure, AWS, and Google Cloud.

Microsoft Azure :

Google Cloud :

Amazon Web Services (AWS) :

Periodic Table of AWS

To see this Article in Indonesian, can be seen here.

That is the explanation of the Comparison of Cloud Services between Google Cloud Platform (GCP), Microsoft Azure, and Amazon Web Services (AWS) that we have explained.

Thank You 😄😊👌👍 :)

Wassalammu‘alaikum wr. wb.